Suing for Wrongful Death

A wrongful death suit is a civil legal claim that a family brings against someone who caused their loved one’s death. While criminal cases are about punishment and jail time, a civil wrongful death suit is about financially making things right. It serves as a way to hold a person or a company accountable for being careless, reckless, or even intentionally causing a fatal accident.

To win this kind of case, the family generally has to show that the other person had a responsibility to act safely but failed to do so, and that failure was the direct cause of the death. For example, if a driver ignores a red light and causes a fatal crash, they have breached their duty to drive safely. Because the legal system cannot bring a person back, it uses money as a substitute to compensate the family for the income the deceased would have earned, the medical and funeral costs, and the loss of the person’s presence and companionship.

Georgia is unique because it focuses on the full value of life from the perspective of the deceased. This means the court considers the full range of what the person lost, not just future paychecks, but also the simple joys of living, such as spending time with family or enjoying a hobby. This ensures that even if the deceased was a child or a retired person who wasn’t earning a salary, their life is still considered legally valuable.

Filing a Wrongful Death Suit

Georgia has a strict priority system in place that tells the court exactly who is allowed to file a lawsuit. Think of it as a ladder where you can only move down to the next person if the person above them isn’t there. This system ensures that only one lawsuit occurs at a time and eliminates confusion about who is in charge. The surviving spouse is at the very top of the ladder. As long as there is a living husband or wife, only they can start the case. Even if the deceased person had grown children or parents who want to pursue a wrongful death suit, they have to wait behind the spouse, who is legally required to handle the case for the benefit of the whole immediate family.

If there is no surviving spouse, the right to sue moves down the ladder to the children. This includes both adult children and minors. Both the adult children and the minors have an equal say in the case. If there is no spouse and no children, the right moves to the surviving parents of the person who passed away. Finally, if there is no spouse, no children, and no living parents, the estate takes over. This estate representative, who handles the lawsuit, is court-appointed, and the money eventually goes to the next closest relatives, such as siblings or grandparents.

The court doesn’t have much flexibility to change the hierarchy of who can file the suit and in what order. For example, a long-term partner who was never legally married to the deceased cannot jump ahead of a sibling or a parent, because the law follows the official family tree. This ensures that the most immediate family members are the ones taken care of first, but it also means that if you aren’t on that specific list, you generally cannot bring a wrongful death claim in Georgia.

Types of Wrongful Death Claims

The family must prove three specific things to show that the death was legally wrong rather than just a tragic accident. The first component is the duty of care, the legal obligation to act with reasonable care. Essentially, the suit must show that the person or company who caused the death had a responsibility toward the deceased. For example, all drivers have a duty to follow the rules of the road just as doctors have a duty to provide proper medical care. This relationship must be established for the law to recognize that the defendant was supposed to be looking out for the other person’s safety.

The second component is the breach of duty. Once the responsibility for safety has been established, it is necessary to prove that the defendant failed to fulfill their obligation. This is the part of the case where you want to show exactly what went wrong. A breach occurs when someone acts carelessly or recklessly, such as a driver who speeds, a company that sells a broken product, or a surgeon who makes a preventable mistake. This is the time to show the court that the defendant did something a reasonable person would not have done in that same situation. Proving this usually requires evidence such as photos, witness testimony, or company records to highlight the specific moment when the defendant’s behavior became dangerous.

The third and often most critical component is causation, which is the direct link between the defendant’s mistake and the person’s death. This is a crucial part of the lawsuit because you must prove that the death happened because of the defendant’s specific actions and not for some other unrelated reason. Your attorney might invoke a but-for test to make this tie. For example, if it weren’t for the defendant’s carelessness, would the person still be alive? If the answer is yes, then causation is proven.

Although it might seem like a separate step, you must also show that the death resulted in damages. For these damages, Georgia uses the phrase full value of life, which covers both the financial loss of future earnings and the intangible loss of the person’s experiences and companionship. This ensures the court has a basis for awarding a specific amount of money to the family.

Instead of being handled by the family, an estate claim is dealt with by the executor or administrator of the deceased person’s estate. While the wrongful death claim looks forward at the life that was lost, the estate claim looks backward at the financial losses that happened between the moment of the injury and the moment of death.

These financial losses can include medical bills from the hospital or emergency room, the costs of the funeral and burial, and conscious pain and suffering. This last part plays an exceptionally critical role. If the person did not die instantly and was aware of their pain before they passed away, the estate can sue for the physical and emotional distress they suffered in their final moments.

While in a wrongful death claim, the money goes straight to the spouse or children, the money won in an estate claim instead goes directly into the deceased person’s estate. This means the money is first used to pay off any outstanding debts the person has, such as hospital bills or credit card debt. Only after these debts have been resolved will the remaining amount be distributed to the heirs in accordance with the person’s will. If the person did not have a will, the estate will be distributed according to Georgia law.

Because these two claims cover different types of losses and have different rules about where the money goes, your attorney might file them at the same time to make sure every single expense and every bit of suffering is accounted for.

Modified Comparative Fault

Even if you are able to prove the three components of duty, breach, and causation, the court must still look at whether the deceased person played a role in their own accident. This is demonstrated through a rule called modified comparative fault. Under this rule, a jury is asked to assign a percentage of fault to each party, with a total of 100%. If the person who passed away is found to be 50% or more responsible for the incident that caused their own death, the family is legally barred from recovering any money at all.

If the deceased was less than 50% responsible, the family can still win, but the deceased’s percentage of fault reduces the total payout. For example, if a jury decides the full value of the life is $1 million but finds the deceased was 20% at fault for not wearing a seatbelt or being distracted, the award is reduced by 20%, resulting in a final payment of $800,000.

This rule intensifies the causation connection, as the defendant’s lawyers will often try to prove the deceased was at least half to blame to avoid paying anything. Because of this, cases usually focus heavily on details such as exact speeds, weather conditions, and the precise timing of events. The goal for your family is to keep the deceased’s fault percentage as low as possible to ensure the family receives maximum compensation.

Type of Damages

The money awarded in a lawsuit is called damages. To cover the different types of losses, it is typically split into two categories. The first and more critical category is for the full value of the life, which is a part of the wrongful death claim. This is when a jury will be asked to measure the value of the life from the perspective of the person who died and not the family members that they left behind. This value is split into economic damages and intangible damages. Economic damages cover the math-based side, which relates to all the money the person would have earned, their retirement benefits, and even the financial value of chores and childcare. Intangible damages cover the human side of life. This is much more difficult to quantify. It is challenging to set a dollar amount on the joys of hobbies or the comfort of familiar relationships. Since the simple joys of living receive their own consideration, a jury has the difficult task of deciding what they consider a fair amount for these lost experiences.

The second category is estate damages, which cover the specific costs that piled up as a result of the accident. Unlike money determined by the full value of life, which goes straight to the family, this money is placed in the deceased person’s legal estate to handle their final affairs. This includes all medical expenses from the ambulance and hospital, as well as the funeral and burial costs. This category also has an intangible element. If the person did not die instantly and was aware of their pain or felt fear before they passed away, the estate can seek money for that physical and emotional trauma. This ensures that the defendant is held responsible for the suffering they caused in the person’s final moments.

In particular and rare cases, there is a third category. Punitive damages are not meant to help the family pay bills or to measure the value of a life, but are in place to punish the defendant for their bad behavior. These are typically only available through the estate claim and are reserved for situations where the defendant acted with malice or a total disregard for safety, such as a drunk driving accident or a violent crime. By awarding these damages, the court is sending a message to the community that such dangerous behavior will not be tolerated and has lasting consequences.

The Statute of Limitations

The statute of limitations is a ticking clock that tells you how long you have to file a lawsuit before you lose your right to do so. For most wrongful death cases, you typically have two years from the date the person passed away to start your legal claim. This deadline applies to both the claim for the value of the life as well as the estate claim. The statute of limitations has a strict cutoff, and if you miss it by even one day, the court will usually refuse to hear your case, no matter how much evidence you have.

However, there are special situations where the clock can be paused. This process is called tolling. The most common reason to pause the clock is if there is a criminal case related to the death, such as a vehicular homicide or DUI. In those instances, the clock can be put on hold until the case is finished, for up to a maximum of six years. The clock can also be paused for up to five years if the deceased person’s estate does not have an appointed executor or administrator at the time of death. These pauses are meant to give families a fair chance to get their affairs in order before they have to worry about a civil lawsuit.

While tolling can give you more time, there are other situations where you actually have much less time to act. If the death involved a government entity, like a city-owned bus, a county police car, or a state hospital, you have to send a formal warning called an ante litem notice. For a city, you usually have just 6 months to send this notice. For a county or the state, you generally have up to 12 months.

For cases involving medical mistakes or broken products, there is a final cutoff called a statute of repose. This can end your right to sue based on when the mistake happened or when the product was first sold, even if the person died much later. Because these deadlines are so varied and strict, you would be well advised to start the process as early as possible.

FAQs

1. Who is allowed to sue? In Georgia, the surviving spouse has the right to file the lawsuit first. If there is no spouse, the children of the person who died can file. If there is no spouse or child, the parents are next in line. If none of those relatives are alive, the executor of the estate files the claim for the benefit of the next of kin.

2. How long do I have to file? Usually, you have two years from the date of the death to file a lawsuit.  However, if a criminal investigation or case is underway at the same time, the two-year clock might pause until the criminal case is over.

3. How do they decide what the case is worth? Georgia law looks at the full value of a life from the perspective of the person who died. This isn’t just about lost wages, it’s about the intangible value of life, like the joy of hobbies and being with family. There is no set limit on how much a jury can award for this. A jury will use its own conscience to pick a fair amount.

4. What if my loved one was partially to blame? You can still win as long as your loved one was less than 50% at fault. But if they reach the 50% mark, the law says the family receives nothing.

5. Where does the money go? Money from a wrongful death claim goes directly to the family and cannot be taken by people the deceased person owed money to. However, money from an Estate Claim goes into the deceased person’s estate first, meaning it can be used to pay off their old debts before the family gets what is left.

Medical Malpractice

A medical malpractice wrongful death suit is a specific type of suit when a healthcare provider’s error leads to someone’s passing. In order to prove medical malpractice, you must show that a doctor or nurse violated the standard of care. The standard of care is a legal standard, meaning that the medical staff failed to act with the same level of skill and caution that a prudent professional in the same field would have used. A bad surgical or medical outcome is not enough to prove that the standard of care was not met, it must be proven that the medical provider made a mistake that other competent practitioners would have known to avoid.

Because medical malpractice wrongful death suits are so technical, Georgia law requires the immediate involvement of an expert. This gatekeeper step is called the expert affidavit. At the very moment you file the lawsuit, you must include a sworn statement from a qualified medical expert who has reviewed the records and identified at least one specific negligent act that led to the death.

Two different deadlines strictly control the timing of wrongful death suits involving medical malpractice. The statute of limitations typically gives the family 2 years from the date of death to file a lawsuit, but there is also a hard deadline of 5 years from the date the mistake occurred. This is called the statute of repose. If a doctor made a surgical error six years ago, but the patient only recently passed away because of complications from that error, the family is usually barred from suing because the five-year window has closed.

A considerable component of many malpractice cases involves the informed consent rule. This rule states that before performing a significant procedure, such as surgery, general anesthesia, or radiation, a doctor must explain the risks to the patient in a way they can understand. The doctor must disclose the common or serious complications that may occur during this procedure. If a doctor fails to warn a patient of a specific risk, and that exact risk happens and leads to the patient’s death, the family can sue for malpractice even if the surgery itself was performed flawlessly. The logic is that the patient was robbed of their right to decide whether the treatment was worth the danger. This rule usually does not apply in life-or-death situations where there isn’t enough time for a detailed conversation, given the nature of the emergency. If a patient is unconscious or unable to communicate, Georgia law presumes that they would want their life saved, and efforts should be made to do so.

Defendants being sued for wrongful death due to medical malpractice can now request a bifurcated trial. This is a two-part process in which the jury first decides whether the doctor is at fault. If they choose that the doctor is responsible, they hold a second mini-trial to determine the amount of damages to be awarded. This process is intended to keep the jury’s focus on the medical facts before they get into the emotional side of the loss.

Commercial Trucking Accidents

A wrongful death case involving a commercial truck, such as a semi-truck or a large delivery vehicle, adds a layer of complexity due to the heavy regulations and the large quantities of evidence involved. These cases are governed by Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration rules, which specify how many hours a driver can work and how well the truck must be maintained. If a driver was fatigued because they skipped a mandatory sleep break to meet a deadline, or if the company ignored faulty brakes, that violation can become a centerpiece of the lawsuit.

To prove these claims, your lawyer will rely on data from the truck’s controls, which record the speed and braking at the time of the crash. In cases such as these, it is essential to send a spoliation letter immediately after the accident. This is a legal order that prevents the trucking company from destroying this data or repairing the vehicle before inspection.

Unlike in other lawsuits, you aren’t allowed to mention that the other person has insurance. Still, in an incident involving commercial trucks, you can actually name the insurance company as a defendant in the lawsuit. This is vital because it ensures the jury knows there is a sizeable financial policy in place available to cover the full value of the life. The trucking company will also bear some responsibility for the driver’s mistakes under a rule stating that, as long as the driver was on the clock, the company’s deeper pockets are on the hook for the damages.

A family can also sue the trucking company for their own corporate negligence. This includes highlighting negligent hiring practices, where a company puts a driver behind the wheel who has a history of dangerous DUIs or reckless driving, and negligent maintenance, where the company fails to perform the safety checks required by law. Because these trucks are so much heavier and more dangerous than passenger cars, these companies are held to a distinctly high standard.

Premises Liability

A premises liability wrongful death suit is filed when a property owner’s failure to maintain a safe environment leads to a person’s death. Owners have a legal duty to exercise ordinary and prudent care to protect people they invite onto their land, such as customers at a store or tenants in an apartment. Their level of responsibility depends on why the person was there. The highest duty is owed to invitees, such as customers or tenants. A lower duty is owed to licensees, such as social guests and trespassers.

To prove negligence, it must be demonstrated that the owner knew or should have known of a danger, such as a rotted balcony or a slippery floor, but the victim did not, and the owner failed to fix it or warn them.

Another aspect of premises liability involves negligent security, which involves a death when someone is killed by a criminal on someone else’s property. For example, if a person is fatally shot at an apartment complex or a gas station, the owner can be held responsible if the crime was deemed foreseeable.

Your lawyer might work to show that there was a history of similar crimes in that same area. If the owner knew their property was dangerous but failed to provide basic safety measures, such as bright lighting, working locks, or security guards, the law views the owner’s negligence as a contributing cause of the death. This allows the family to seek the full value of the life from the business or landlord.

However, property owners will often use a defense called the open and obvious rule to avoid paying. They will argue that the hazard, such as a large hole in the ground or a clearly broken staircase, was visible enough that any reasonable person should have seen it and avoided it. If a judge or jury decides the danger was open and obvious, or that the victim had equal knowledge of the danger, the family may be barred from recovering any money.

Workplace Accidents

When a person dies due to a workplace accident, the Georgia Workers’ Compensation Act mandates that the legal process is handled differently than a typical lawsuit. The law effectively creates a trade-off. Beneficiaries get guaranteed financial benefits without having to prove the employer did anything wrong. Still, in exchange, they usually lose the right to file a traditional wrongful death lawsuit against the employer or a co-worker. This means that even if the company was extremely careless or ignored safety rules, the family generally cannot sue them for the full value of the life. Instead, they receive specific death benefits, which might include up to $10,000.00 for burial expenses, or weekly checks for a surviving spouse or children.

There is a significant exception called a third-party claim, which is often the only way a family can recover the full value of a life after a workplace tragedy. While you cannot sue the employer, you can sue a different person or company if their negligence caused the death. For example, if a worker dies because a piece of heavy machinery was manufactured poorly, the family can file a wrongful death suit against the machine manufacturer. Similarly, if a worker is killed at a construction site by someone working for a completely different subcontractor, that other company can be sued. In these cases, the family can go beyond the limited options available to them and ask a jury for the full economic and intangible value of the life, just as they would in a car accident case.

Investigation and Evidence Gathering

The investigation phase is the most critical part of a wrongful death case because it is where the story of the person’s life and the facts of the accident are woven into a strong legal strategy. Because the burden of proof is on the family to show the defendant was at fault, this process is much more involved than simply reviewing a police report. It requires a deep dive into two different worlds: the technical details of the accident and the personal history of the person who died.

The first half of the investigation focuses on proving that the defendant is responsible. Your lawyer will often act like a private detective to preserve evidence before it disappears. In a car or trucking accident, this might include pulling data from the vehicles, which shows the exact speed, braking time, and steering movements in the seconds before a crash. They also look for digital footprints, like cell phone records to prove distracted driving or GPS data from commercial trucks. In cases involving business properties or apartment complexes, the investigation involves scouring records or police call logs from the surrounding neighborhood to prove the owner knew the area was dangerous but failed to add security.

The second half of the investigation is unique to the full value of life standard. Since the jury must decide what the deceased’s life was worth, the legal team must gather evidence that shows the person’s character, passions, and relationships. This involves collecting humanizing evidence, such as family photo albums, work awards, and even letters and journals. Attorneys will often interview witnesses, friends, or neighbors who can testify about the person’s daily life and their impact on the community. This creates a complete picture so the jury isn’t just looking at a name on a piece of paper, but at a human being whose life had immense personal value and joy.

In most wrongful death cases, the investigation includes hiring highly specialized experts to provide scientific weight to the family’s claims. For the economic side, a forensic economist is brought in to calculate precisely how much the person would have earned over their lifetime, even factoring in inflation and specific tax laws. For the technical side, a 3D digital simulation of the accident can show the jury exactly how the defendant’s breach of duty caused the death. If the case involves a medical mistake, a medical expert will extensively review hospital charts to find where and how the standard of care was ignored. These experts must take the raw evidence gathered during the investigation and turn it into testimony that a jury can easily understand.

Filing the Complaint and Service

The filing and service stage is the formal process of moving your case from a private investigation into a public legal record. This process begins with a document called the complaint, which acts as a detailed story of the case. It identifies the person filing the suit, names the defendant, and explains exactly how the defendant’s carelessness caused the death. This document is filed electronically with the Clerk of Court in the necessary county. Along with the complaint, you must pay a filing fee to the court, and the clerk then issues a summons, which is an official order telling the defendant they are being sued and have 30 days to respond.

Once the paperwork is filed, the next critical step is service of process, which is the physical delivery of the lawsuit to the defendant. Georgia law is very strict about how these papers are to be delivered. A deputy sheriff or a professional process server must hand-deliver the summons and complaint to the defendant in person. If you are suing a corporation or business, the papers must be delivered to its registered agent, the specific person the company has chosen to handle legal matters. Once the hand-off happens, the server signs a sworn statement for the court to prove the defendant was officially notified.

After the defendant has been served, their 30-day clock officially starts ticking. During this time, the defendant, usually through an attorney hired by their insurance company, will file an answer. In this document, they respond to every claim in your complaint, generally denying fault to defend themselves in court. If they fail to file this answer within the 30-day window, they risk losing the case automatically through a default judgment. This entire exchange of paperwork is what sets the stage for the rest of the lawsuit.

The Discovery Phase

The discovery phase is the longest and most involved part of a wrongful death lawsuit. It is essentially a formal fact-finding period that begins shortly after the defendant files their answer. During this time, both sides are legally required to share information with each other. This ensures that there are no surprises at trial and that both parties have a clear understanding of the evidence. Discovery typically lasts at least 6 months, though it can be extended for up to 1 year or more in complex cases.

Interrogatories are one of the first tools used in discovery.  These are sets of written questions that each side must answer in writing and under oath. For a family filing a wrongful death suit, these questions might ask for the deceased person’s medical history or the names of any witnesses. For the defendant, these questions might focus on their training, their actions on the day of the incident, or their company’s safety policies. Along with these questions, your attorney will use this time to make requests for production to demand physical evidence.

The most critical part of the discovery phase is the deposition. This is a face-to-face meeting where a person, such as a witness, family member, or the defendant, must answer questions out loud while a court reporter types every word. These answers are given under oath, meaning they carry the same legal weight as if they were given in the presence of a judge. Depositions are vital in Georgia wrongful death cases because they allow your family’s lawyer to see how a witness will behave on the stand and to lock in their story. If a witness changes their story later at trial, the deposition transcript can be used to prove they are being inconsistent.

The discovery phase also includes the exchange of expert disclosures. Since Georgia law requires a jury to determine the full value of the life, both sides will hire experts to provide their opinions. For example, the family might employ an economist to explain the deceased’s future earnings. During discovery, these experts must provide reports explaining their findings. It is likely that the opposing side will then depose these experts. This allows both legal teams to see the scientific and technical arguments that will be presented to the jury, often leading to settlement discussions once the strengths and weaknesses of each side are revealed.

Mediation and Settlement Talks

Mediation is a formal meeting where both sides try to settle the case without going to a trial. It usually happens after the end of discovery, meaning that both sides have seen all the evidence and have a perspective on what the full value of the life looks like on paper. In many Georgia counties, judges will order the parties to mediation because it is often the best way to resolve these deeply emotional cases in a private, more controlled setting.

The process is led by a mediator, who is a neutral third party. They are often a retired judge or an experienced lawyer who has handled hundreds of wrongful death cases throughout their career. The mediator’s job is not to decide who is right or wrong, but to help the family and the defendant reach an agreement.

One of the most significant benefits of mediation is its confidentiality. Unlike a public trial, where all of the sensitive details of the person’s life and the details of the accident become public, what is said in mediation remains confidential. For the family, this is often the first time they get to hear a genuine apology or see the defendant take some level of responsibility through a financial offer. It also gives the family a sense of closure and control, because they get to decide whether to accept a settlement today, rather than leaving the outcome to twelve strangers on a jury who might take months to reach a decision.

If an agreement is reached, the lawyers will sign a memorandum of understanding on the spot, a binding contract that ends the lawsuit. The insurance company will usually issue a check within 30 days. However, if the two sides are too far apart and cannot agree on a number, the mediation ends in an impasse. If that happens, the case continues moving toward a trial.

Choosing a Structured Settlement

When a wrongful death case results in a significant award, the family often chooses to receive payment through a structured settlement. In some cases, this method of payment will be required by the court. Instead of getting a single lump-sum check, the money is placed in a specialized financial plan that pays out over several years or even decades. This is often done with a high-quality insurance annuity, which provides a guaranteed stream of income. The main goal is to provide long-term financial security, ensuring that the money doesn’t run out and is available to cover future needs, such as a child’s college tuition or a spouse’s retirement.

One of the most significant advantages of a structured settlement is its flexibility and the considerable tax benefits it offers. You can design the payments to fit your life. For example, you might receive a monthly salary to replace the deceased’s income, plus larger payments every five years for significant expenses. Under federal law, the interest and growth on this money are typically tax-free for wrongful death victims, which means the total amount of money you receive over time is often much higher than the original settlement amount. This structure also protects the family from predatory individuals or poor investment decisions that can occur when someone suddenly receives a life-changing amount of cash.

Georgia courts almost always require a structured settlement when a minor is involved. Because a minor cannot legally manage a large sum of money, the court will often require that the funds be placed in a blocked account or an annuity until the child turns 18 or 21. This ensures that the money is explicitly preserved for the child’s future and isn’t spent by guardians or relatives on other things. It provides a safety net so that when the child reaches adulthood, they have the financial support their parent would have wanted to provide.

Schedule a Case Evaluation with The Claiborne Firm

When you lose a loved one, the world stops, but the insurance companies do not. At the Claiborne Firm, we believe that the worst day of your legal battle should be the day before you hire us. From that moment on, you are no longer alone. You are entrusting your anxieties to a team dedicated to providing your family with the personalized, assertive attention you deserve.

You do not have to be a victim of the legal system while you are mourning a victim of negligence. Whether through the collaborative, solution-focused environment of mediation or the fierce advocacy of a trial, we are here to ensure you are the most prepared person in the room. Preparation is the key to winning, and the side that knows the facts better wins.

Areas Serviced: